It’s Always the Husband by Michele Campbell

Michele Campbell’s debut thriller, It’s Always the Husband, came at a much needed time when I was looking for escapist fiction. Do you get mystery/thriller withdrawal like I do? If my thoughts are a little jumbled, it’s because I’m coming off of some major writer’s block. A column I wrote was approved for publication a few months ago, and then rejected a few weeks later. As a result, I took some time to just read and recoup!  It’s time to get back in the game, and I’m so excited to review this book!

It’s Always the Husband is a mystery that is told in two parts. The first part is a recounting of the history of three very dissimilar colleges roommates (in temperament, socioeconomic status, and personality) during their time at college. A tragic accident (or is it?) happens and changes the dynamic of their ever-changing relationships. The second part is present day, with a murder prompting the friends to revisit their role in the aforementioned accident. Violence begets silence, and it’s quite the page-turner.

This book gave me the slightest of flashbacks to my favorite book, The Secret History. A small college on the East Coast, filled with privileged children and the multi-flavored family drama of their pre-college lives (a social worker’s dream!). Just add a dash of college-town politics and a 20-year post-college history (and yes, not so “Greek” as TSH).

Ruth Ware’s endorsement on the cover states: “A page-turning whodunnit that will speak to anyone who’s ever had a fremeny.” The word “fremeny” has always been so problematic for me (friend + enemy…usually just means enemy). However, in this story, the love/hate dynamic of the friends totally fits the definition.

Image result for its always the husband book

Our main girl, Kate (antagonist? protagonist?) reminded me of some other famous characters- some real, some fiction. The wounded, well-to-do blonde is a common character in mysteries (maybe we have Hitchcock to thank?), and the Campbell’s take on the device/character was so well done. I was fascinated with Kate and how polarizing she was in her community.

Kate brought to mind these ladies, in particular:

Image result for blair warner facts of life
Blair Warner, Facts of Life icon of affluent beauty


Image result for serena van der woodsen new york
Serena Van Der Woodsen, NYC junior socialite on Gossip Girl
Image result for marilyn monroe sad
Marilyn Monroe, known for her beauty and her many addictions

This book was rich with characterization, and I was genuinely surprised at the ending. Campbell writes not just a murder mystery, but a story about the power of betrayal in friendships and how omission can be just as bad as lying in any relationship. A subtle undercurrent of the role of privilege is here, too, showing how motivation for financial comfort can alter our moral values when they are tested.

Highly recommend this one!

Rating: 4 stars

Further Reading:

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s